Select Page

Destructive Passion: Freud’s Metapsychology of Hate in “Instincts and their Vicissitudes”

by | Vol 30 (3) 2012

This contribution proposes that Freud, in “Instincts and their Vicissitudes” (1915c), develops a separate metapsychology of hate for the first time. Freud does not only distinguish hate from sadism and masochism, but also renounces his former opinion about hate as a transformation of love. We analyse Freud’s views on hate in line with his “The Disposition to Obsessional Neurosis” (1913i) and according to the matrix of obsessional neurosis. We also draw attention to the constitutive importance of the ego-development and the ego-instincts as put forward in “On Narcissism: An Introduction” (1914c). In this way Freud’s plea for an original hate is one of the rare locations in the Freudian corpus where there is room for an original, non-sexual aggressivity.

Related articles

  • On Structure and Function in Freud's Metapsychology: an Historic Approach

    This paper begins by outlining the debate at the beginning of the twentieth century between structuralist and functionalist psychology. We examine some of the consequences of emphasizing either the functional or the structural properties of the mental apparatus. The functional explanation finds its most extreme example in Watson's behaviorism. Then we examine Freud's notion of the mental apparatus. We find that in the metapsychology of 1915 Freud gives priority to a structural explanation of mental phenomena, while in the metapsychology…

  • Freud contra Laplanche: On Sadism and Masochism in "Instincts and their Viscissitudes"

    This contribution focuses on Freud's elaboration of the genesis of sadism and masochism in "Instincts and their Vicissitudes" (1915c). We first briefly recap the standard reading of this text by Jean Laplanche which relies on Freud's concept of "anaclisis". In our opinion, Laplanche's reading implicitly presupposes that Freud's discussion of sadism and masochism questions the sexualisation of an originally non-sexual aggressivity. In contrast, we argue that Freud's argumentation starts from the question how the aggressivity that is inherent in sexuality…

  • Freud en de archeologie

    Download full Text